As I read Goldstein’s list of jabs from philosophy jeerers,
I could not help but be struck by the irony. After all, isn’t the belief that
philosophy is unnecessary a philosophy itself? What if I told you it was my opinion
that all opinions are stupid, you would call me crazy would you not? These so
called jeerers are actually saying what most people throughout history, both
philosophers and non-philosophers alike, have said: all philosophies are wrong
except for mine.
In
answer to the specific accusation that philosophy has made no progress since
the time of Plato, considering Plato’s continuing prominence in the field to
this very day, I would suggest the argument can easily be flipped around.
Fields such as mathematics and the sciences have only in relatively recent
history produced figureheads whose names will always be relevant to their
respective studies. John Nash, Albert Einstein, and even Gregor Mendel are a
few examples of the greats who have come long after Plato’s day. These brief observations
would lead me to ever so humbly suggest to mathematicians and scientists who
disregard the relevance of the study of philosophy that perhaps this is
evidence that their areas of study are only now beginning to catch up with the
accomplishments achieved by one of the first philosophers. And he didn’t even
have coffee or a chalk board!
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.