In On Liberty, Mill stated, “He who knows
only his own side of the case, knows little of that.” He elaborates by
explaining that it is not enough to receive approval from individuals who agree
with you, it is more important to search out those who disagree to “be able to
hear them (arguments) from persons who actually believe them; who defend them
in earnest, and do their very utmost for them. He must know them in their most
plausible and persuasive form; he must feel the whole force of the difficulty
which the true view of the subject has to encounter and dispose of, else he
will never really possess himself of the portion of truth which meets and
removes that difficulty.” This wisdom should be shared with our elected
officials.
Currently
a select group of thirteen Republican Senators met in secret to draft a health
care bill. I seriously doubt that they sought any input from Democratic members
of the Senate who might have raised questions that needed to be addressed
before the bill was presented to the full Senate. Sadly, if the roles were
reversed and the Democrats controlled the Senate, they may have followed
similar procedures; neither would be good for the country.
Mill’s reasoning
is perfectly logical. Abraham Lincoln was said to prepare for his legal cases
by spending more time preparing for the case as if he were the opposing lawyer.
Once he had determined what his opponent’s strategy would be, he would prepare
his case by attacking each of the opponent’s points. If the Republican Senators
really wanted to craft a successful healthcare bill, they would have invited
every Democratic Senator into the room and understood what their reasons were
for wanting to keep and modify the Affordable Care Act. Then they could have
made reasoned arguments, point by point, on why it should be repealed. They
didn’t do that because they didn’t want to learn the truth. As Mill says, “they
have never thrown themselves into the mental position of those who think
differently from them, and considered what such persons may have to say; and consequently,
they do not, in any sense of the word, know the doctrine which they themselves
profess.”
P.S. I emailed my essay to Senator Corker and encouraged him to read On Liberty over the 4th of July break.
How many US senators could pass a 20-question test on Mill?
ReplyDeleteCan we set the over/under at 25?
DeleteHey that is a great idea seeing if a US senator would understand an essay on Mill lol.
ReplyDelete