Up@dawn 2.0

Monday, October 8, 2012

Section 19 Group 4 Tolerance

Last Wednesday we finished our political pod casts with a discussion over Tolerance by Wendy Brown. She starts off by giving an universal definition saying, " tolerance is all about the management of some undesirable element of foreign body, invading or taking up residence within the host. Brown then goes on to explain that a level of personal tolerance is necessary to get along the world, but when the principle is raised to a political level it can have negative effects. "It cloaks inequalities; it even sometimes substitutes egalitarian principles". She uses 2008 election issues, such as gay marriage, to help illustrate her point, saying that many people said they were not for marriage inequality, rather tolerance. Brown makes the point that this implies that some people have to be tolerated rather than made equal in our society. Our groups main discussion point came from the question, at what point are you tolerating, and what point are you just, for lack of a better word, not caring? Many of us agreed that a lot issues that have no affect on us we tend to have no opinion of, and don't get involved in disagreements or debates concerning those matters. Is that considered tolerance? And is that one of the negative effects that Brown was worried about? It seems that everyone has at least one issue where they would cross the blurry line of tolerance and voice their opinion, so its safe to assume that problems will  arise when it comes to certain groups "being tolerated" , rather than equally incorporated into our society.

Questions

Why does Brown prefer the term tolerance to toleration?

What does Brown say that tolerance has become a substitution for?

3 comments:

  1. Is it possible for a person to have no tolerance at all? I know that Wendy Brown say that everyone has some form of tolerance, but i disagree and would say their are people that do not have tolerance.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Does Wendy Brown believe that tolerance is a central virtue of any liberal democracy?

    Yes

    I believe tolerance falls short of consistency.
    It is necessary though to be tolerant in treating others with different religions or viewpoints, otherwise violence might just break out.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Factual Question: Does Wendy Brown believe tolerance is always bad? No ("I am not against tolerance, but I do want to submit it to close scrutiny, to ask what the concept is actually doing.")
    Discussion Question: In what ways is tolerance appropriate and when is it harmful?

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.