Up@dawn 2.0

Monday, September 17, 2012

Hakuna Matata Section 19 group anselm and Aquinas

We started by discussing how this reading was very different and kind of hard to understand. But also that it was refreshing to take a different perspective on the subject of God. We started discussing Aquanis's the idea that God was the end of the uncaused-cause idea. But how do we know that God is the cause? but as humans we all want an answer and an ending point. We started asking ourselves if we personally believed that there was a strating point. We then talked about Anselm's idea that because you have an idea of God means that it exists. To us this doesnt really make sense. Though Anselm did say that this only works for God because he is the perfect form of anything. We then talked about Aquinas's five ways that were meant to demonstrate that God exisits. We established that Anselm and Aquinas disagreed about how to prove God exist. Aquinas believed there must be a starting point. Anselm believed that because everyone has an idea of God means that he has to exist.

3 comments:

  1. Our discussion today was very interesting and introduced alot of interesting ideas. Though Anselm and Aquinas's ideas were a little confusing.

    Question:
    Factual- True or false? Descartes believed in sceptisism?
    Discussion- Do you believe with Descartes method of cartesian doubt?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Trevor Broaddus10:36 AM CDT

    I really enjoyed talking about the uncaused-cause. I find it a very cool yet mind-bending idea. I also enjoyed a different take on religion, talking about ideas and reasoning behind its core beliefs. Infinite regression also intrigued me, which says their is no "uncaused cause" but rather a never-ending line of causes/effects.

    Questions:
    Factual - Did Descartes ultimately distrust his senses, thinking them a form of trickery?
    Discussion - What is your view on Descartes believing more in the presence of the human mind rather then the body? What was his argument?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Megan White11:14 AM CDT

    I missed our last class. It sounds like you all had an interesting discussion.
    Factual: What is Descartes Method of Cartesian Doubt?
    Discussion: Can anyone really live their life not trusting anything? Especially their own senses and thoughts.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.